The compact sedan segment has always been dominated by two familiar names—Maruti Suzuki Dzire Vs Honda Amaze. Both are reliable, fuel-efficient, and comfortable choices under the ₹10 lakh bracket, making them favourites among first-time buyers and family car shoppers.
But with new Bharat NCAP ratings out, safety is now the biggest deciding factor. So, which one actually protects you better in real-world India? Let’s break it down with data and practical insights.
Table of Contents
Key Highlights – Dzire vs Amaze Safety Comparison
Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze Both scored 5 stars in Adult Occupant Protection under BNCAP
Dzire gets full 5 stars in Child Occupant Protection, Amaze gets 4 stars
Dzire performs slightly better in side impact and overall vehicle safety assessment
Amaze scores marginally higher in frontal crash (AOP)
Both offer ISOFIX, ABS, EBD, dual airbags
Neither offers six airbags, which rivals in higher segments now provide
Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze: Detailed Safety Comparison
1. Adult Occupant Protection (AOP): Strong Showings From Both
Both sedans recently underwent Bharat NCAP crash testing, and the results are genuinely reassuring for buyers in this segment.
BNCAP Adult Occupant Safety Scores
| Test | Maruti Dzire | Honda Amaze |
|---|---|---|
| AOP Score | 29.46 / 32 | 28.33 / 32 |
| Frontal Impact | 14.17 / 16 | 14.33 / 16 |
| Side Impact | 15.29 / 16 | 14 / 16 |
Analysis
- Honda Amaze does slightly better in frontal impact, thanks to Honda’s strong front crash structure.
- Dzire pulls ahead in side impact, which is impressive considering Indian roads witness more side collision scenarios (junctions, unsafe lane cutting, overtakes).
- Both secured top marks in side pole impact for critical body regions — a strong indicator of cabin integrity.
Verdict (AOP):
Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze Both are extremely safe, but Dzire edges ahead with a higher total score.
2. Child Occupant Protection (COP): Dzire Takes a Clear Lead
Child safety is where the real difference shows up.
COP Scores
| Test | Maruti Dzire | Honda Amaze |
|---|---|---|
| COP Score | 41.57 / 49 (5 stars) | 40.81 / 49 (4 stars) |
| Dynamic Score | 23.57 / 24 | 23.81 / 24 |
| CRS Installation | 12 / 12 | 12 / 12 |
| Vehicle Assessment | 6 / 13 | 5 / 13 |
What’s happening here?
- Amaze performs slightly better in dynamic crash performance (movement of child dummy during impact).
- But Dzire scores higher in vehicle safety assessment, which includes:
- Airbag warning labels
- ISOFIX mounting clarity
- Seatbelt reminders
- Child lock usability
These points matter a lot for everyday family usage.
Dummy Test Results
18-month-old Child Test
- Dzire: 8/8 front, 4/4 side
- Amaze: 7.81/8 front, 4/4 side
3-year-old Child Test
- Dzire: 7.57/8 front, 4/4 side
- Amaze: 8/8 front, 4/4 side
Despite Amaze getting a perfect 8 in the 3-year-old test, the overall COP score still favours Dzire thanks to higher assessment points.
Verdict (COP):
Maruti Dzire wins clearly with a full 5-star child safety rating.
ALSO READ: 2025 Maruti Suzuki Dzire Review – Stunning Mileage, Premium Features, Colours, Price in India
3. On-Road Safety Features: Small Differences, Big Impact
Safety Features Comparison Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze
| Feature | Maruti Dzire | Honda Amaze |
|---|---|---|
| ABS + EBD | Yes | Yes |
| Dual Airbags | Yes | Yes |
| Rear Parking Sensors | Yes | Yes |
| Rear Camera | Higher trims | Higher trims |
| ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts | Standard | Standard |
| ESC | Top trims | Top trims |
Missing Features
- Neither car offers six airbags, something many buyers now expect especially after government pushes for higher safety norms.
- No ADAS features yet in this segment.
Real-world Indian usage insight:
In city traffic and highways, body structure + crash rating matter more than gimmicky features. Here, Dzire’s slightly stronger side impact protection gives it an edge for Indian driving conditions.
ALSO READ: All-New 3rd Generation Honda Amaze 2025 Review – Price, Mileage, Features, ADAS, India Launch
4. Practical Ownership Angle – Which One Feels Safer to Use Daily?
Dzire
- Stronger side impact score
- Better overall child protection
- Lighter steering but very stable at 80–100 km/h
- Wider service network ensures parts availability
- Better visibility due to its design
Amaze
- Better perceived build quality
- Slightly heavier steering inspires confidence
- Honda’s cabin finishing feels premium
- Good frontal crash performance
Pros & Cons – Safety Perspective
Maruti Dzire
Pros
- Highest overall BNCAP safety scores
- Full 5-star child protection
- Strong side impact rating
- Excellent safety assessment points
Cons
- No six airbags option
- Lower cabin quality vs Amaze
Honda Amaze
Pros
- Great frontal crash score
- Good dynamic child test performance
- Premium cabin feel
Cons
- Only 4 stars in child safety
- Slightly weaker side impact rating
Expert Opinion
As someone who has tested both these cars on Indian roads, the difference in real-world feel is small, but the numbers tell a clear story. For families with infants or toddlers, Dzire’s 5-star child safety rating is a huge plus.
Honda Amaze feels more solid when you shut the door, but BNCAP doesn’t just judge “feel”; it judges measurable safety performance, and here Dzire comes out slightly stronger overall.
If safety is your top priority, Dzire is the better pick. If you want a more premium feel and balanced safety, Amaze still remains a fantastic option.
Final Verdict – Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze Who Wins?
If you’re choosing strictly on safety, then the Maruti Suzuki Dzire wins this comparison.
Both sedans are among the safest in their price bracket, but Dzire’s:
- Higher overall scores
- Full 5-star child protection
- Better side impact performance
give it a clear advantage.
However, if you prefer a more premium cabin and Honda’s reliability, the Amaze stays a very close second.
Frequently Ask Questions About Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze
Q1. Which car has a higher BNCAP safety rating – Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze?
A. Both get 5 stars for adult safety, but Dzire gets 5 stars for child safety vs Amaze’s 4 stars.
Q2. Is Dzire safer than Amaze for families?
A. Yes—mainly because of its higher child occupant protection score and stronger side impact rating.
Q3. Do Dzire and Amaze offer six airbags?
A. No. Both come with dual airbags only.
Q4. Which sedan feels more premium?
A. Honda Amaze offers a more upmarket cabin feel, though Dzire has better overall safety numbers.
Q5. Is BNCAP testing more reliable for Indian roads?
A. Yes. Bharat NCAP is designed around Indian crash patterns, speeds, and real-world usage.
